Finance · 111 calculators
Car Insurance Deductible Calculator
A higher deductible lowers the premium but raises what you pay when you claim. The right level is where the annual saving beats the expected extra cost of claiming.
Last updated
Net annual benefit
$225.00
- Annual premium saving
- $300.00
- Expected extra cost of claiming
- $75.00
Values update as you type. This calculator covers the single scenario its formula assumes — see Common Mistakes for what it leaves out.
The formula this calculator uses
Net benefit = (low-deductible premium - high-deductible premium) - extra exposure x claim frequency
- saving
- Annual premium reduction from the higher deductible
- exposure
- Extra deductible you would pay per claim
- frequency
- Expected claims per year
How to check the result by hand
- 1
Get both premiums
Ask your insurer for the annual premium at the low deductible and at the higher one, with everything else in the policy identical.
- 2
Find the annual saving
Subtract the higher-deductible premium from the lower one. That is what you keep each year by accepting more risk.
- 3
Work out the extra exposure
Subtract the low deductible from the high one. That is the extra you pay each time you make a claim.
- 4
Estimate your claim frequency
Use your own history or a market average, roughly one claim every seven years, or about 0.15 a year, for a typical driver.
- 5
Compare saving with expected cost
Multiply the extra exposure by the frequency and subtract it from the saving. A positive result means the higher deductible is worth it on average.
Common Questions
How does the Car Insurance Deductible Calculator work?
Raising the deductible cuts the premium, but you take on more of each claim. Multiply the extra deductible by how often you claim in a year, and subtract that from the premium saving. If the saving beats the expected extra cost, the higher deductible is worth it.
What do I need to enter in the Car Insurance Deductible Calculator?
It takes 5 inputs: Lower deductible, Higher deductible, Annual premium at lower deductible, Annual premium at higher deductible, Expected claims per year. Fields that expect a unit say so next to the label.
Where does Net annual benefit come from?
It comes from Saving = low-deductible premium - high-deductible premium — the premium you give up each year by choosing the higher deductible.
What is the most common mistake with the Car Insurance Deductible Calculator?
Choosing a deductible you could not afford. Insurance exists to move risk you cannot carry. A deductible you could not pay turns a covered loss into a crisis, which defeats the purpose.
For worked examples, common mistakes and the limits of this formula, read the full How To Calculate Car Insurance Deductible page.
